At 2 p.m. on a Sunday, the dining room at Sal & Judy’s is crowded with families of all sizes and ages. An 89th birthday cake sits ready to be presented to what is no doubt a longtime fan of this Lacombe establishment.
Lush, buttery, cream-covered crab legs and seafood cannelloni — stuffed with a generous filling of crabmeat (or crawfish) — share the table with eggplant parmigiana and oversized meatballs topped with red gravy. The fragrance, one of olive oil, Italian spices and that indescribable scent of Sunday dinner at Nonna and Nonno’s (Italian for grandmother and grandfather), tells you exactly where you are: Sal & Judy’s.
But even if you don’t have an official Nonna or Nonno, it doesn’t seem to matter here. And that stuffed artichoke isn’t just sitting on the table as decoration. The food here is meant to be shared, meant to be passed around. This food carries a little bit of Sicily, a little bit of New Orleans and a whole lot of family — the Impastatos.
When Sal Impastato landed in New Orleans in 1960 at age 18 from his native Cinisi, Sicily, he went to work with his uncle, Mr. Joe Impastato, at Napoleon House. Sal also worked at Moran’s, La Louisiane and Old Absinthe House. He met Chef Chris Kerageorgiou while working as a bartender at the Royal Orleans Hotel, following Chris first to Dallas and then to Lacombe, where Chris opened La Provence.
In 1974, he and his then-wife, Judy, opened Sal & Judy’s in a former gas station in Lacombe. In 2000, Sal began building a larger restaurant next door, with more room for diners and an expanded kitchen. Today this neighborhood spot north of Lake Pontchartrain still draws diners from across the region.
Sal, now 84, still comes into the restaurant at 9 a.m., five days a week, to cook. Even on Sundays. Two of his sons, Jimmy and Nicki Impastato, join him in the kitchen. His son Joe is a co-owner of the restaurant.
“He doesn’t call himself a chef,” Joe says of his father. “They still do everything the same way they did when they first opened the door.”
Sal dices every onion himself. The restaurant makes its own pasta, grinds its own beef and gets fresh seafood from local fishermen. Sal grew up on a farm in Sicily. “My dad understands ingredients, so he’s really good at knowing if something is good or not,” says Joe. “We add more spices than you would in a typical Sicilian dish,” says Joe. “The food is cooked slowly.”
The bruscioloni, beef stuffed with cheese, Italian sausage and ground beef, and the spiedini, smaller Sicilian meat rolls filled with seasoned breadcrumbs, are all sliced, filled and rolled by hand.
Sal was one of six children, but only he and his brother Joe, who owns Impastato’s in Metairie, settled in America. At least one of his sisters still makes the trip from Sicily every year, staying for weeks and making arancini while she’s here. Sal says his sister Sarah is the best cook in the family. “And she’ll let you know it, too,” he adds.
Then there is Sal’s lasagna, which reflects both the family’s Sicilian roots and the Louisiana influences on Sal’s cooking; it’s layered with béchamel, red gravy, peas and cheese. “The peas are what makes it traditionally Sicilian,” says Joe. “The red gravy makes it local.”
